Posted by **Kira** on Monday, March 5, 2007 at 7:32pm.

Hi. I have a few calculus problems that I have to do using the washers and shell method to find out what the volume of the graph rotated is. I'll post one question at a time with my work. The problem is, I should be getting the same answer for the problem with the shell method and the washer method, but I'm getting two different answers. If someone could check my work, it would be GREATLY appreciated! And please keep explanations in as easy a form as you can. I'm having a really hard time understanding these concepts. THANKS!!!

1. Find the volume of the solid that results when the region bounded by y=x and y=x^2 from x=0 and x=1, is resolved about the x axis. Apply both the shell and washer method to solve.

My work:

SHELL:

h=y

r=sqrt(y)

2pi(INT from 0 to 1)y*sqrt(y)dy

2pi(INT from 0 to 1)y^3/2dy

2pi[2/5y^5/2]from 0 to 1

4pi/5 ANSWER

WASHER METHOD:

R=x

r=x^2

pi(INT from 0 to 1)x^2-x^4 dx

pi[1/3x^3 - 1/5x^5]from 0 to 1

pi[5/15 - 3/15]

2pi/15 ANSWER

I don't know how to do shell method, but, I'd say do it on your calculator and see which answer is right and go from there

Your second answer is right. In the first one, the hight is y but the radius is (sqrt(y)-y). Look at a graph to see why. So:

2pi(INT from 0 to 1)y(sqrt(y)-y)dy

2pi(INT from 0 to 1)[y^(3/2)-y^2]dy

2pi[(2/5)y^(5/2)-(1/3)y^3]

=2pi/5 Answer