February 26, 2017

Homework Help: science - controlled experiment

Posted by Laura on Wednesday, December 13, 2006 at 6:29am.

This doesn't seem like it should be that hard, but it is.

List the 2 parts of a controlled experiment.

_____ variable-- the factor that is not being tested (know expected outcome)

_____ variable -- the factor that is being tested

I feel like the answers should be dependent and independent in that order, but the definitions of those don't really seem to fit

The best I can do for the first is "control". However, the definition offered in the question is vague.

The second definition is worse. One does not test variables, one tests the hypothesis by manipulating variables. The person writing this seems not to understand that. The best I can offer is independent, or manipulated.

When you get exam questions such as this, bite your lip and go on. You will have some good exam question writers, and you will have some others.

As a science educator, I have no idea what the writer is trying to determine here. We in science do not test variables. We test models, and hypothesis, by manipulating variables and observing the outcomes. So the use of the word "tested" in these definitions is an aberration.

Here is a summary of the experiment that might be even more helpful.

An independent variable is the potential stimulus or cause, usually directly manipulated by the experimenter, so it could also be called a manipulative variable.

A dependent variable is the response or measure of results.

Extraneous variables — other than the independent variable — potentially can affect the dependent variable, so they must be controlled. If possible, you try to keep them constant between the experimental and control group.

The experimental group receives the independent variable.

The control group is similar to experimental, except it does not receive the independent variable. Extraneous variables are balanced between experimental and control groups.

Types of experiments

1. Single blind gives the control group a placebo — a substance that is inert, it has no physical effect. Subjects don't know if they are in experimental or control group to reduce placebo effect, a change in behavior solely due to believing that you are getting the independent variable.

2. Double blind keeps both subjects and experimenter ignorant of group setup. Distribution of the independent variable and placebo is controlled by third party. This controls for experimenter bias and self-fulfilling prophecy. This means that experimenters with particular expectations are likely to consciously or unconsciously to bias the experiment and influence it to conform to their expectations.

As an example, suppose you want to find out if fluorides reduce dental cavities. You would find two groups, trying to control the extraneous variables. Extraneous variables are found by surveying previous research in the area. In this case, you would match the groups in terms of previous history of cavities, diet and dental hygiene habits including how and how often they brush their teeth.

The experimental group would get toothpaste with the independent variable, the fluoride, while the control group would not have the fluoride in their toothpaste. The toothpaste without the fluoride would be the placebo.

The dependent variable would be the number of cavities after participating in the experiment for a time. The dependent variable indicates the results, but it is not the results. At the end of the experiment, both groups could have no change in cavities or one of the groups could have a greater reduction in cavities. (Of course, if the fluoride increased cavities, you wouldn't want to use it.) All of these varied results would be indicated in terms of the dependent variable.

If only the subjects do not know who is getting the fluoride, it is a single blind experiment. If both the subjects and experimenter do not know, it is a double blind.

I hope this helps a little more. Thanks for asking.

Answer This Question

First Name:
School Subject:

Related Questions

More Related Questions